Pros and Cons of Allowing Tenants to Sublet Your Property

Pros and Cons of Allowing Tenants to Sublet Your Property

Before diving into subletting, it’s essential to understand the pros and cons of allowing tenants to sublet your property.

Subletting a property has become an increasingly popular practice among landlords and tenants alike. And it offers various advantages and opportunities for both parties.

Subletting a property can offer potential cost savings for landlords. However, it also has potential pitfalls, including dubious tenants, property damage, and financial risks.

To mitigate these issues, a well-drafted subletting agreement should clearly define terms. By addressing these factors, landlords and tenants can navigate the subletting process more effectively and enjoy a successful subletting experience.

This blog post will discuss the pros and cons of subletting and the pitfalls to be aware of. It will also detail how to create a successful subletting tenant agreement. The objective is to ensure a smooth and mutually beneficial experience for all parties involved.

What is subletting?

Before we dive into the pros and cons of allowing tenants to sublet your property, let’s define subletting.

Subletting, or subleasing, occurs when a tenant rents out their current rental property to another tenant, either partially or entirely. The original tenant remains responsible for the property and its monthly payments in this arrangement. However, the subtenant pays the original tenant a portion or the entire rent.

When a sublease is created, the existing tenant becomes the sublandlord, and the new tenant becomes the sublessee. The original tenant may be referred to as the master tenant or prime tenant.

And the original lease may be called the master lease or prime lease. Although the landlord is not directly involved in the sublease agreement, their consent is usually required before the property can be sublet.

Various reasons may prompt a tenant to consider subletting. For example, businesses may choose to sublet their rental property. Perhaps they’ve downsized and have excess rented space, or maybe they need to relocate to a different location. In some cases, tenants might also sublet if they struggle to pay rent.

Subletting vs assignments

It’s essential to understand the difference between subletting and assignments. Subletting is a temporary arrangement, while an assignment is a permanent transfer of tenancy.

In an assignment, the tenant transfers all their rights and obligations to a new tenant, who then deals directly with the landlord. Unlike subletting, the original tenant is no longer responsible for the rent after assigning the lease to another party.

The different types of subletting tenancy agreements

Regarding subletting, there are two primary types of sublease agreements that tenants and subtenants can enter into. Each type serves a different purpose and has distinct characteristics.

And it’s essential to know the difference when weighing up the pros and cons of allowing tenants to sublet your property.

Short-term sublease

In a short-term sublease, the original tenant temporarily leaves the rental property. This may be due to an overseas work assignment, a family medical issue, etc.

During this time, a subtenant rents the property for the duration of the original tenant’s absence. The original tenant intends to return to the rental unit after the short-term sublease ends.

The subtenant typically has no direct contact with the landlord in this arrangement. They pay rent to the original tenant. And the original tenant also handles any complaints, issues, or repair requests on behalf of the subtenant.

Permanent sublease

A permanent sublease occurs when the original tenant moves away permanently and finds a subtenant to take over the rental unit for the remainder of the lease.

If the subtenant assumes the role of the new primary tenant, this is referred to as an “assigned lease” or “assignment.” It is important to note that an assignment cannot be done without the landlord’s consent.

In a permanent sublease, the subtenant often has no direct contact with the landlord either. They pay rent to the original tenant, who remains responsible for dealing with complaints, issues, or repair requests from the subtenant.

However, the subtenant takes over all responsibilities in an assignment and communicates directly with the landlord.

Jul 30 - comparewise business loan banner

How does subletting work?

Before engaging in a sublease, it’s crucial to ensure that the lease, the landlord, and the state laws permit subletting. Laws regarding subletting vary from region to region.

Some require landlord approval, while others may have no specific regulations. In many cases, commercial leases may outright prohibit subletting or only allow it with the landlord’s consent.

The following is an overview of how subletting works:

Check the lease and provincial laws

Before considering subletting, tenants should review their lease agreement and consult the applicable laws to determine if subleasing is allowed.

If the lease prohibits subletting, the tenant must seek consent from the landlord if required. However, if subletting is not permitted by law, the tenant should refrain from engaging in such an arrangement.

Choose the type of sublease

Short-term subleases typically last for six months or less, providing flexibility for both the tenant and the subtenant. This arrangement allows the subtenant to test the rented space without a long-term commitment.

At the same time, the tenant can evaluate the sublessee’s suitability before renewing the contract.

Long-term subleases offer stability, as the subtenant can stay in one place and pay a fixed rent for a more extended period. This arrangement also allows the original tenant to spend less time searching for a subtenant.

Draft the sublease agreement

The tenant and subtenant must create a sublease agreement that outlines the terms and conditions of their arrangement. This agreement should incorporate the prime lease by reference, as the original lease remains in effect during the subletting period.

It’s important to note that a sublease does not affect the relationship between the landlord and the original tenant. The prime lease continues to bind both parties, and the tenant remains responsible for meeting their obligations under the lease. This includes rent payments and property maintenance.

Do I have to permit subletting of my property?

As a property owner, you may wonder whether you are obligated to allow your tenants to sublet their rented space. It’s a crucial question when exploring the pros and cons of allowing tenants to sublet your property. The answer to this question depends on the specific provincial laws and the terms outlined in your lease agreement.

Generally, tenants are permitted to sublease a property unless the lease or provincial law states otherwise. If your lease explicitly prohibits subletting or requires the landlord’s permission, the tenant must adhere to these conditions.

A landlord’s refusal to allow subletting should be based on reasonable grounds. An example would be upholding restrictions mentioned in the lease, such as limiting the use of the premises to specific purposes. However, a landlord cannot refuse a sublease merely to renegotiate the master lease or demand higher rent.

Some landlords may prefer to select their tenants based on specific criteria or have a list of interested parties they would rather consider. In some instances, landlords might allow tenants to terminate their lease agreement early and assign the property to a new tenant.

The tenant can take legal action if a landlord refuses a sublet request without a valid reason. However, this is not an ideal solution and should be a last resort.

Violating the building’s rules or the Residential Tenancies Act (RTA) by subletting without permission or using the property as a short-term rental can have severe consequences.

Pros and cons of allowing tenants to sublet your property

pros and cons of allowing tenants to sublet your property - comparewise

Subletting benefits

Examining the key benefits is the first port of call when investigating the pros and cons of allowing tenants to sublet your property. And these are some of the core benefits you could enjoy.

1. Rental history preservation

Subletting legally and with transparency enables tenants to maintain a positive rental record. By adhering to the terms of their tenancy agreement, tenants can foster a healthy relationship with their landlord and avoid potential disputes.

2. Property security

Short-term subletting agreements can offer added security for a property when the tenant is away. Having someone occupy the space and engage in daily activities helps deter break-ins and vandalism.

3. No vacancy

When tenants must leave their rental mid-lease, landlords might face a rental vacancy and lost income. Allowing subletting can help prevent this situation and ensure continuous rental payments.

4. Tenant responsibility

With subletting, the original tenant is responsible for finding a subtenant and may also be liable for any issues arising from the subtenant’s occupancy.

This arrangement can reduce the workload for the landlord, as the original tenant handles potential problems.

5. Financial responsibility of original tenant

The original tenant remains financially responsible for the rent when subletting. Their credit is at stake, incentivizing them to find responsible subtenants who consistently pay rent.

6. Increased tenant occupancy and rent

Landlords may benefit from increased rent when tenants sublet, as additional occupants can lead to extra wear on the property.

This arrangement can help both parties financially, as tenants reduce their expenses and landlords increase their income.

7. Improved property maintenance and relationships

Subletting can promote better property maintenance when responsible tenants and subtenants take an active role in upkeep.

Additionally, working with aligned businesses, such as moving companies, can help landlords attract ideal renters and reduce property management challenges.

8. Building a pool of potential future tenants

By allowing subletting, landlords can potentially discover reliable, long-term tenants. Suppose a subtenant proves to be responsible and respectful during their sublet period.

In that case, the landlord may consider offering them a direct lease in the future, simplifying the tenant search process.

9. Flexibility and adaptability

Subletting provides both landlords and tenants with flexibility and adaptability in response to changing life circumstances or market conditions.

This flexibility can result in more satisfied tenants and higher retention rates, ultimately benefiting the landlord in the long run.

10. Strengthening tenant-landlord relationship

Allowing subletting can foster a stronger relationship between the landlord and the tenant, built on trust and open communication.

When landlords show understanding and support for their tenants’ needs, it can lead to long-lasting, positive relationships and potentially result in more reliable, long-term tenants.

11. Diversifying tenant base

Subletting can lead to a more diverse tenant base in a rental property. This diversity can enhance the sense of community and create a more vibrant living environment, which may appeal to prospective tenants and contribute to higher occupancy rates.

12. Demonstrating competitiveness in the market

By allowing subletting, landlords demonstrate that they are competitive and responsive to the needs of their tenants. This adaptability can make their property more attractive to prospective renters, resulting in lower vacancy rates and increased rental income.

Subletting pitfalls

Another crucial aspect when determining the pros and cons of allowing tenants to sublet your property is the pitfalls. This section of our blog post will detail the most notable cons associated with subletting your property.

1. Risk of dubious tenants

Subletting your property can open the door to potential tenants who may not be the most reliable or trustworthy. Conducting background checks on all applicants can help filter out those with poor credit records or previous rental issues.

Be thorough with your research and ask the right questions. Remember not to offer your property on a first-come basis but give yourself the option to choose the best applications.

2. Possibility of lease theft

In some cases, unscrupulous subtenants may bypass the original tenant and sign a rental agreement directly with the landlord upon lease renewal. Alternatively, they might refuse to move out when the original tenant is due back.

Evicting such tenants can be a time-consuming, costly, and unpleasant process, which is why it’s crucial to choose your subtenants wisely.

3. Potential for property damage

Subletting your property may expose it to a higher risk of damage, especially if the subtenant isn’t familiar with the rules. It’s essential to check whether your renter’s insurance policy covers subtenants.

If not, consider removing your personal belongings before signing the space over. Remember that any damages caused by the subtenant will likely come from your security deposit.

4. Inconsistent screening procedures

Suppose the landlord does not require screening of subtenants. In that case, there’s no guarantee of the calibre of the tenant subleasing the property.

The original tenant may prioritize finding someone to cover the rent over assessing the subtenant’s qualifications, which can lead to problems down the line.

5. Reduced landlord control

Subletting may reduce the landlord’s control over the leased property, as they are not a party to the sublease.

The landlord must rely on the prime tenant to ensure that the subtenant adheres to the lease terms, which can lead to complications if the prime tenant isn’t vigilant.

6. Impact on property values

Excessive subletting can negatively impact property values in a neighbourhood, as high rental rates can flatten property values. Overcrowding, parking difficulties, and increased utility costs can make the area less appealing to prospective buyers.

7. Tenant profit-making

Some tenants may try to profit behind the landlord’s back by adding a surcharge to the rent they charge their subtenant. This can lead to disputes and legal issues if discovered, so landlords need to monitor their properties and maintain open communication with their tenants.

8. Eviction challenges

If a subtenant turns out to be problematic, the landlord may need to evict them, which can be lengthy and costly. Sometimes, the landlord may even need to evict the original tenant.

To minimize this risk, ensure proper screening and clear communication between all parties involved in the subletting process.

Successful subletting tenant agreement terms

Now that you’ve weighed the pros and cons of allowing tenants to sublet your property, you can make a more informed decision. And if you decide that subletting is for you, you’ll need to consider what you’re tenant agreement will look like.

To avoid any subletting nightmares, we recommend employing the following when drafting your tenant lease agreement:

  • Include a detailed description of the property, its condition, and allowed usage to ensure mutual understanding.
  • Outline circumstances for subtenant default and steps to remedy the situation, providing a clear resolution path.
  • Require the landlord’s consent or written permission for subleasing, giving the landlord control and awareness.
  • Mandate consistent screening procedures for all subtenants, ensuring thorough selection.
  • Detail sublease logistics, including timeframe, end date, deposit, and cleaning, to minimize confusion.
  • Obligate subtenants to have renter’s insurance, providing financial protection for all parties.
  • State rent from subtenants must be paid directly to the landlord, ensuring fair pricing.
  • Explicitly ban short-term sublets to maintain control over the property and its occupants.

Pros and cons of allowing tenants to sublet your property conclusion

Navigating the complexities of subletting can be a challenging but rewarding endeavour for landlords. As you ponder the pros and cons of allowing tenants to sublet your property, consider the importance of open communication with your tenants.

Stay current with local laws and regulations regarding subletting to maintain compliance and avoid potential legal issues. And don’t hesitate to consult with a real estate attorney or property management expert for guidance and advice tailored to your specific situation.

Taking these proactive steps can ensure a smoother subletting process and make the most out of your property investment.

You might also like…

Discover Investment Opportunities

Make your money do more.

12 Results

Advertiser disclosure

Offers shown here are from third-party advertisers. We are not an agent, representative, or broker of any advertiser, and we don’t endorse or recommend any particular offer. Information is provided by the advertiser and is shown without any representation or warranty from us as to its accuracy or applicability. Each offer is subject to the advertiser’s review, approval, and terms. We receive compensation from companies whose offers are shown here, and that may impact how and where offers appear (and in what order). We don’t include all products or offers out there, but we hope what you see will give you some great options.

Young investors can trade stocks and ETFs, all for free.
Min Investment
Target Return
Retire up to 30% wealthier with Questwealth Portfolio.
Min Investment
Target Return
Get $20 CAD of BTC with promo code: COMPAREWISE
Min Investment
Target Return
Buy and sell gold, silver & platinum online at the best price.
Min Investment
Target Return
Get up to $150 cash bonus
Min Investment
Target Return
Flexibility with a great return.
Min Investment
Target Return
Get a $50 bonus when you sign up and deposit $250.
Min Investment
Target Return
Buying and securing gold has never beeng more simple and affordable.
Min Investment
Target Return
High return on a shorter term.
Min Investment
Target Return
Get a $100 welcome bonus, when you make your top-up*
Min Investment
Target Return
A new passive income asset class, peer-to-peer lending.
Min Investment
Target Return
Sign Up And Access 65+ Cryptocurrencies Instantly
Min Investment
Target Return

FAQs about the pros and cons of allowing tenants to sublet your property

What happens if my tenant sublets without my permission?

If your tenant sublets without your permission, they may be in violation of the lease agreement. You can address the issue by discussing it with the tenant, issuing a warning, or potentially initiating eviction proceedings if necessary.

Can I charge a higher rent if I allow subletting?

You may be able to charge a higher rent for allowing subletting. Still, it's important to communicate this clearly in the lease agreement and ensure that the increase is reasonable and within legal limits.

How can I minimize the risk of property damage from subtenants?

To minimize property damage risks, ensure a thorough screening process for subtenants, require renter's insurance, and establish clear rules and guidelines for the subtenants to follow.

Can I limit the number of times my tenant can sublet the property?

Yes, you can specify limitations on the frequency of subletting in the lease agreement. This can help maintain control over your property and prevent constant turnover.

What can I do if a subtenant violates the terms of the sublease agreement?

If a subtenant violates the sublease terms, you can work with the original tenant to address the issue or, if necessary, take legal action to enforce the lease terms and protect your property.


April 25, 2023
Fact Checked

Grow your finances today.

By submitting, you agree to comparewise’s terms of use and privacy policy.

You may also like

If you need money or are in need of some creative financing for your business, you shou...
Quarantine might have gotten the creative gears in your brain running if you’re wonderi...
Anyone who wants to succeed on a global scale must know the specifics of global transac...
What is business casual, and how do you dress for this particular style? This can be co...
If you’re running a business, you should know by then how important it is to build busi...
Car loan?
Personal Loan?

Top deals await you just a short
application away!